Simply Approved Mortgages
Compare

Cap Rate vs Cash-on-Cash Return

These two metrics answer different questions and investors lose money by confusing them. Cap rate is NOI divided by value — it strips financing out entirely so two properties can be priced against each other. Cash-on-cash is annual pre-tax cash flow divided by the cash you actually invested, so it reflects your leverage, your closing costs, and your rehab dollars. A property has one cap rate and as many cash-on-cash returns as there are ways to finance it.
Start My ApprovalSee Today's Rates
AttributeCap RateCash-on-Cash Return
FormulaNOI ÷ property valueAnnual pre-tax cash flow ÷ total cash invested
Includes debt serviceNoYes
MeasuresThe assetYour position in the asset
Used forPricing and comparing propertiesDeciding where your capital goes
Affected by leverageNoHeavily
Counts closing costs and rehabNoYes, as cash invested
Counts appreciation and principal paydownNoNo
Common healthy rangeMarket-specific, often 5%–8% on stabilized rentalsOften 6%–12% year one on a stabilized rental

Best for Cap Rate

  • • Comparing two properties
  • • Valuing small multifamily from NOI
  • • Measuring value-add created

Best for Cash-on-Cash Return

  • • Choosing between deals for your own capital
  • • Testing leverage scenarios
  • • Judging whether a down payment is well used
Can cash-on-cash be higher than cap rate?

Yes, whenever borrowing costs less than the property yields and you put in less cash. That is positive leverage. When the loan constant exceeds the cap rate, leverage works against you and cash-on-cash falls below the cap rate.

Which one do lenders care about?

Neither directly on a DSCR loan — lenders size against DSCR, the ratio of rent to the full housing payment. Cap rate and cash-on-cash are investor metrics; DSCR is the credit metric.

Which should I use to make an offer?

Both, in order. Use cap rate to test whether the price is supported by income in that submarket, then use cash-on-cash to test whether your capital is better deployed here than in the next deal.

Get pricing

Initial scenario review once we have credit authorization and your supporting documents — usually same day. Formal pricing follows underwriting.

Start My Approval

Other comparisons

Ready to move on your next deal?

Complete the short pre-qualification form and upload your supporting documents, and a licensed loan officer will follow up with an initial scenario review.

Get Your Personalized Rate Quote
Simply Approved Mortgages Expert Insight
Last reviewed

How We Evaluate This Scenario

A DSCR file is judged on the property, not your tax returns: qualifying rent divided by PITIA — principal, interest, taxes, insurance, plus HOA and flood where they apply. Most programs use the lesser of the in-place lease rent and the appraiser's market rent, so a lease signed below market usually caps the ratio no matter how strong the comps look.

Three inputs move the outcome more than anything else: rent support on the appraiser's rent schedule (Form 1007 or 1025), the LTV tier, and the credit tier. Dropping leverage by five points or moving up a FICO band frequently changes pricing more than shopping a different lender does.

Before you write an offer, price taxes and insurance at post-sale levels rather than the seller's current bill. In reassess-on-transfer states and in coastal insurance markets, that single adjustment is the most common reason a deal that penciled at contract fails the ratio at underwriting.

Reviewed by Simply Approved Mortgages · NMLS #2620881. Business-purpose investor lending only.

Investor pre-approval

Get your personalized investor loan quote

Pick the loan type that fits your deal and complete a short, tailored pre-qualification. A licensed loan officer follows up with an initial scenario review once we have your credit authorization and supporting documents — usually the same business day. Formal pricing and terms follow underwriting.

Pick a loan type

You can change this any time.

Tell us about your scenario

The form below is tailored to DSCR rental loan — only the questions your program needs.

1
Your info
2
Your deal
Your deal — the basics

Purchase or refinance a rental. The property's rent qualifies the loan.

What's your goal?
Purchase price ($)$450,000
$
Down payment (%)20%
%
Monthly rent ($)$2,800
$
HUD Fair Market Rent for your ZIP — ballpark only. Get a precise market rent after you submit.
Estimated credit rating

A soft self-estimate — no credit pull happens here.

This is a pre-qualification request — not a loan application under TILA/RESPA and not a loan approval, rate lock, offer, or commitment to lend. It does not trigger a Loan Estimate. If your loan requires one, the Loan Estimate is issued inside our loan origination system after you submit a complete application and your loan officer has reviewed your scenario.

Encrypted and never sold. Takes about 60 seconds.

Your answers save as you go. A licensed loan officer typically follows up the same business day · Simply Approved Mortgages LLC, NMLS #2620881.

Credit & pre-approval

Why we pull credit for your investor loan pre-approval

Every DSCR / business-purpose loan file needs a tri-merge credit report so we can verify identity, price your rate tier accurately, and confirm reserves and payment history for the underwriter. Cleaner credit typically unlocks a better rate and higher leverage.

Pay for your credit report — SmartPay

Simply Approved Mortgages uses MeridianLink SmartPay to securely collect the credit report fee for your investor pre-approval. Payment goes directly to the credit vendor — not to us — and unlocks your tri-merge report (Equifax, Experian, TransUnion) so your loan officer can price your file.

  • Secure, PCI-compliant checkout hosted by MeridianLink
  • Required for a formal investor pre-approval decision
  • Soft-touch process — your loan officer will guide you through it
Pay for credit report securely

You'll be redirected to cic.cra.xedalink.net (SmartPay).

Check your credit first — $1 trial at MyITINCredit

Before you apply, it's smart to know exactly where your credit stands. MyITINCredit offers a $1 trial for 15 days that includes all three credit reports and scores (Equifax, Experian, TransUnion), plus ongoing credit monitoring so you can catch errors, dispute inaccuracies, and watch for identity theft.

  • See all 3 bureau reports & scores before your lender does
  • Ongoing monitoring alerts you to new accounts or score changes
  • Fix errors early — cleaner credit can widen your investor loan options
Start $1 / 15-day trial

You'll be redirected to myitincredit.com. Third-party service — terms apply.

Credit report fees are paid directly to the credit vendor. Simply Approved Mortgages does not profit from the credit pull. MyITINCredit is an independent third-party service; pricing, terms, and features are set by that provider.

Investor newsletter

Rates, market shifts, and program changes — in your inbox.

Periodic investor updates: rate movement, guideline and program changes, and market data refreshes. No spam, unsubscribe anytime.

  • DSCR rate snapshots
  • Program & guideline updates
  • Illustrative investor scenarios
  • Market data notes
Get the investor update
Investor newsletter

Periodic DSCR rate updates, market data refreshes, and program changes. No spam, and we never sell your address.

I agree to receive periodic investor market and program update emails from Simply Approved Mortgages LLC. I can unsubscribe at any time. Submitting this form records your consent and the page you signed up from. It is not a loan inquiry and does not start an application.

Start My ApprovalCall (877) 813-7219